play dough (DIY Carrot playdough- http://www.thatswhatchesaid.net/2014/play-dough-recipe/)
Annie's snacks- they are in the shape of bunnies!
small stuffed animals (I am personally not a fan)
little ponies or hot wheels
small dress up accessories
little gardening tools
coloring books and crayons
finger puppets (see link below for some DIY ideas)
gift cards-Sonic (fast food place), iTunes, Google
tie (boy) scarf (girls)
If you are feeling crafty and have a few mins to spare: A.tell me your secret and B. here are some easy FREE printables that would make a great basket filler.
First we have Egg coupons from U-createcrafts.com. These are super cute and easy... just print, cut, and fill your eggs! These will be in my kids eggs when they go hunting.
Next one I found is geared towards younger kids but if my older one gets board enough at church he'll play with them too. Easter Lacing Cards from Everydaydishes.com. Again, easy peasy and I'm going to laminate mine so they last longer.
If you are feeling REALLY crafty this website has a list of 8 different finger puppets you can choose from ranging from quick and kid friendly to I hope you've got more than a few mins. to spare. All cute and great!